So, China is now in my rearview mirror as I’m back in California dealing with myriad life issues. I’ve been back almost three weeks, but haven’t had the wherewithal to throw up these last few short videos. (Besides, WordPress, in addition to telling me I’m about to exceed my storage limit, is telling me these videos are private?) Oh well…
Perhaps I’ll conclude that chapter with the following on the difference between Freedom and Harmony, or perhaps the values of the West vs. the East? It occurred to me that this may be a fundamental difference between Occidental and Oriental philosophy, or world view, weltanschauung, zeitgeist, or social character?
For a long time now, I’ve considered myself a reformed Confucianist, in that I value the ideals of Meritocracy and Filial Piety.
It’s true that a fair meritocracy is hard to achieve if not everyone starts at the same place. The rich kid who gets an enhanced education from the get go has an advantage over the poor kid who has to help the family survive. However, I’ve seen lots of smart poor kids who can hold their own in a meritocratic system. Perhaps that can be tweaked to be more equitable? In any case, the SAT, APs, IBs, or whatever test their using in China, gives everyone a goal for proving their worth, their merit, and that should matter. Why? Because education is important. Your knowledge, skills, and abilities should determine your destiny. Not the accidents of your birth, parental wealth, geography, or other whims of fate and circumstance…
Don’t you agree, that filial piety should be a virtue and a determiner of the social order, if we aspire to longevity, and believe that time might impart wisdom? Of course there are ignorant old people, centenarians noteworthy only for a number, not the content of their character, or their CV. But experience is right there with education on résumés, and as someone once said, “ya don’t get old bein’ no fool!” Further, it is an individual characteristic that transcends race, creed, color, gender, and other arbitrary determinants of identity. I’m also of the opinion that this is one of the advantages that Easterners have over Westerners, perhaps because it confers some humility which in turn urges one to make up for a lack of experience with more education?
Or not? In any case, while in China, it occurred to me that the Confucian value of Harmony might be better for society than the American (European?) value of Freedom. But lemme argue with myself first. Harmony may be surrendering to autocracy, and freedom may be the superpower of individualism. Freedom is strength and harmony is acquiescence? And perhaps the rise of the West is proof of this? But to everything there is a season, and perhaps a reason, and the times they are a-changin’…
Is freedom so important because slavery is part of the Western social order? Does capitalism not require it? Is the worker and manager relationship not the same as slave and master? Even if paid, are the proletariat not slaves to the system? And does the system not extol freedom because it enslaves us, and we must rationalize our servitude as voluntary?
Certainly, the Eastern social order has had slavery, the servitude of the concubines and eunuchs to the emperor class. The divine right of kings and the mandate of heaven are one and the same. Feudalism, aristocracy, yup yup. And maybe harmony is a rationalization as well? Don’t rock the boat, stay in your lane, follow those footsteps to your grave. But harmony is less delusional. And, rather than fighting the social order for social mobility, harmony makes one feel more part of the social order, and perhaps that is comforting?
Certainly, acting on that virtue, is there not more social harmony. Whereas, the exercise of one’s freedom runs into others exercising theirs. Boats capsize, head-on collisions, lost wanderers? Nowadays, are we not oft told of the importance of relationships? Perhaps that that rugged individualism causes an epidemic of loneliness? Were we to find more harmony with others, singing in a choir rather than alone in the shower, would there not be more happiness, contentment, and the music of conviviality?
In any case, the USA seems to be in chaos, its institutions in decline, our social order on the verge of civil war – if we could just get off the couch? Whereas China seems to be ascendant, its institutions growing and thriving, its social order becoming ever more successful. Too much surveillance, maybe? Too little freedom, for what? Enough, yes! (Other thoughts on this topic.)
Thanks for coming along with me this far, but I recommend going to China and exploring that country and culture for yourself. And if you can’t see these videos, keep scrolling or check some links or go for a walk outside!
Cheers….
Just outside Zhangjiaxie National Park…
In Shenzhen…
Hong Kong tram rides, etc…
Last Didi ride to the airport…
This concludes randomvail.
Find me elsewhere…
谢谢










































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































